As for my last
blog post for the semester, I am going to end it on a good note and talk about
the movie that we watched in class last week and how it compares to real
American history. The movie that we watched was “An American Tail.” This film
follows a family of rats that flee from oppression brought on by cats in their
home country of Russia, and end up making their way to the west to America in hope to start over with the idea that there are no cats in America.
On their way over on the ship, one of the youngest in the family gets separated
from the rest and ends up having to fend for himself for most of the movie. The
youngster who is known as Fievel starts looking all over the place in the city
of New York for his family who at this point think he is dead. Well push comes
to shove, they end up reuniting and all is well. This is just a quick synopsis
of the story so anyone that hasn’t seen it can be caught up. What I am
going to delve into for this post is the message that this movie gives off and
how it is very similar to what the people that immigrated to this country had
to go through.
Well first, what
is interesting to me about this film is that the rats that are coming over to
America have just about the same feeling towards America as people did during
the immigration period. The rats thought that they would be free from the
oppression of the cats, just like people thought that they could escape the
things that were happening in their own country. This whole idea that the rats
had about there being no cats in America and the streets were paved with cheese
is not as ridiculous as it may seem. When people were immigrating over to
America they all had this concept of what was known as the “American Dream.”
But when they got
over to America, there was still a lot of hardship. The rats still had to work
hard to provide for their family just like the people did, and there were cats
as well. Now, based on the cats being there they represent a good message. That
message is hardship. Whether it is rats or people they both wanted to get away
from the hardships that plagued them, but when they made it to America the
hardship continued. But even though there was hardship, that did not stop the
rats from doing what they needed to do in order to provide for themselves this
is the same for the people that immigrated to America they didn’t stop just
because it got a little hard.
The other thing
that I wanted to talk about is the idea that this movie seems to be directed
more to older kids who are in a middle school or high school History class, but does have a
story for younger audiences as well. For the younger audience, it is about a
little rat that has to find his family. That is pretty cut and dry and is
easier to understand. For the older crowd, there is a bigger picture which is,
the idea that a family is facing the hardships that I discussed earlier and there
was this idea of what we discussed in class, the “American Dream.” I believe
that this film does a very good job conveying that message over. And also, it
seems to be more accurate in the story than that of what Disney did with
“Pocahontas”.
When Disney made
“Pocahontas”, there were many inconsistencies with it and the real story. I
have a blog post that you could refer to that would show you all of these
inconsistencies. As for “An American Tail,” even though it is about a bunch of
rats trying to go to America to escape cats and start over, it is more accurate
as to what happened back when immigration was a big thing. Even though this
film is much darker than “Pocahontas” I think that it is the better of the two because
of its historical significance.
With that I will
close out this blog post and leave it open for discussion and will be willing
to read your comments.